Anyone else using youtube-dl at YT on a regular basis? Recently it seems that DLs seem to have slowed to about 1/10th the speed.

--- BBBS/Li6 v4.10 Toy-5
* Origin: The Rusty MailBox - Penticton, BC Canada (1:153/757)

Re: youtube-dl?
By: August Abolins to All on Sat Jan 22 2022 08:23 am

Anyone else using youtube-dl at YT on a regular basis? Recently it seems that DLs seem to have slowed to about 1/10th the speed.

I use it and 4K Video Downloader (for Windows) sometimes too/instead. I'm amazed (and very glad) that YT lets them work at all! :-)
--
digital man (rob)

Synchronet "Real Fact" #91:
Captured chat with Wayne Bell: http://wiki.synchro.net/history:waynebell_chat Norco, CA WX: 65.6°F, 21.0% humidity, 6 mph NW wind, 0.00 inches rain/24hrs
--- SBBSecho 3.14-Linux
* Origin: Vertrauen - [vert/cvs/bbs].synchro.net (1:103/705)

Re: youtube-dl?
By: Rob Swindell to August Abolins on Sat Jan 22 2022 02:19 pm

Re: youtube-dl?
By: August Abolins to All on Sat Jan 22 2022 08:23 am

Anyone else using youtube-dl at YT on a regular basis? Recently it seems that DLs seem to have slowed to about 1/10th the speed.

I use it and 4K Video Downloader (for Windows) sometimes too/instead. I'm amazed (and very glad) that YT lets them work at all! :-)

BTW, I can confirm, youtube-dl is very slow (e.g. 52.56KiB/s) these days. But I think it's been that way for a while now, at least for me.
--
digital man (rob)

Synchronet/BBS Terminology Definition #51:
MODEM = Modulator/Demodulator
Norco, CA WX: 65.9°F, 21.0% humidity, 4 mph W wind, 0.00 inches rain/24hrs
--- SBBSecho 3.14-Linux
* Origin: Vertrauen - [vert/cvs/bbs].synchro.net (1:103/705)

Hello, August!

Saturday January 22 2022 08:23, you wrote to All:

Anyone else using youtube-dl at YT on a regular basis? Recently it
seems that DLs seem to have slowed to about 1/10th the speed.

What about yt-dlp?
https://github.com/yt-dlp/yt-dlp

Best regards,
dp.
--- GoldED+/W64-MSVC 1.1.5-b20180707
* Origin: No rest for the wicked (2:5001/100.1)

Hello Dmitry Protasoff!

** On Sunday 23.01.22 - 01:43, Dmitry Protasoff wrote to August Abolins:

Anyone else using youtube-dl at YT on a regular basis?
Recently it seems that DLs seem to have slowed to about
1/10th the speed.

What about yt-dlp?
https://github.com/yt-dlp/yt-dlp

I dunno.. DOES it manage to achieve faster downloads? I
won't be able to try it for several days the next time at a DSL
connection.

Thanks for the heads-up on that one. It's only for the 64bit
on Windows, but it might be a good replacement on one of my /64
systems just the same.

--
../|ug
--- OpenXP 5.0.51
* Origin: (2:221/1.58)

Hello Rob Swindell!

** On Saturday 22.01.22 - 14:31, Rob Swindell wrote to August Abolins:

I use it and 4K Video Downloader (for Windows) sometimes
too/instead. I'm amazed (and very glad) that YT lets them
work at all! :-)

Is there something that YT can detect to disallow it entirely?

I got a bit frustrated with 4K VD for some sreason and decided
to stick with youtube-dl. ytd also allows downloading any
video file that has a direct link. It works on Rumble and
Vimeo videos too.

BTW, I can confirm, youtube-dl is very slow (e.g.
52.56KiB/s) these days. But I think it's been that way for
a while now, at least for me. --digital man (rob)

Thx for that. I only noticed the slowdown within a week or
two.
--
../|ug
--- OpenXP 5.0.51
* Origin: (2:221/1.58)

On 2022 Jan 22 08:23:08, you wrote to All:

Anyone else using youtube-dl at YT on a regular basis?

i use it but i wouldn't say regularly... mostly for grabbing some rocket launch videos for later analysis...

Recently it seems that DLs seem to have slowed to about 1/10th the
speed.

that could be caused by any number of things in the path from the server's file system to your system's file system, really...

eg:
overloaded router in the path
active virus scanner scanning all traffic on the wire
DDOS on the sending or receiving end


FWIW:

i just pulled ULA's recent Atlas V launch video (Uz8zGWycsOY) and it seems to be averaging 78KiB/s for a 17.4MiB file... i guess that's ok... this with the 2021 Dec 17 update of youtube-dl... i can't say if that's good, bad, or average, though...

yt-dlp pulls the same video much much faster (3 seconds vs 3 minutes) but the output is slightly different (both video and audio are webm as is the final container vs youtube-dl's webm and m4a with final container being mkv)... i may not have everything installed that yt-dlp wants, though...

in both cases of the above video, i see the same "playback problem" at the same position in the 25 second video but this may be due to playing them on this older system... the "problem" being large lag of the video image starting about 13 seconds into the video... this lag is not seen when playing the video directly from youtube on the same system, though...

)\/(ark

"The soul of a small kitten in the body of a mighty dragon. Look on my majesty, ye mighty, and despair! Or bring me catnip. Your choice. Oooh, a shiny thing!"
... I trust him as much as I'd trust a programmer with a soldering iron.
---
* Origin: (1:3634/12.73)

Hello mark lewis!

** On Sunday 23.01.22 - 04:43, mark lewis wrote to August Abolins:

Recently it seems that DLs seem to have slowed to about
1/10th the speed.

that could be caused by any number of things in the path
from the server's file system to your system's file
system, really...

eg:
overloaded router in the path
active virus scanner scanning all traffic on the wire
DDOS on the sending or receiving end

Maybe it's just a recent/temporary slowdown across the
platform? I'm getting the same poor results whether on DSL or
mobile hotspot.

..it seems to be averaging 78KiB/s for a
17.4MiB file... i guess that's ok... this with the 2021
Dec 17 update of youtube-dl... i can't say if that's good,
bad, or average, though...

I had good +650KiB/s speed with the same (most recent) youtube-
dl version right up to about 2 weeks ago.

yt-dlp pulls the same video much much faster (3 seconds vs
3 minutes) but the output is slightly different (both
video and audio are webm as is the final container vs
youtube-dl's webm and m4a with final container being
mkv)... i may not have everything installed that yt-dlp
wants, though...

Wow. With yt-dlp at full speed vs youtube-dl toggled down then
the slowdown may indeed be something that YT is detecting with
youtube-dl usage and therefore adjusting the speed afterall.
Haven't tried yt-dlp yet. I know that I can use VLC to do
conversions.

in both cases of the above video, i see the same "playback
problem" at the same position in the 25 second video but
this may be due to playing them on this older system...
the "problem" being large lag of the video image starting
about 13 seconds into the video... this lag is not seen
when playing the video directly from youtube on the same
system, though...

Thx for chining back with the comparisons. Looks like yt-dlp
wil be the next goto program for me. I'm trying to DL a 311MB
file (already using the "-f 18" option in youtube-dl for a
lower quality version) ..but even that is taking 1hr 40min at
an average 50-60KiB/s. :(

--
../|ug
--- OpenXP 5.0.51
* Origin: (2:221/1.58)

Rob Swindell wrote to August Abolins <=-

BTW, I can confirm, youtube-dl is very slow (e.g. 52.56KiB/s) these
days. But I think it's been that way for a while now, at least for me.

Same here. But only for YouTube. Other sites work much faster. So I think YouTube is throttling.


... Sharks don't eat lawyers. Professional courtesy.
=== MultiMail/Linux v0.52
--- SBBSecho 3.14-Win32
* Origin: Diamond Mine Online BBS - bbs.dmine.net:24 (1:275/89)

August Abolins wrote to Dmitry Protasoff <=-

What about yt-dlp?
https://github.com/yt-dlp/yt-dlp

I dunno.. DOES it manage to achieve faster downloads?

The (very quick, unscientific test) that I just did was MUCH faster.


... Some days you're the windshield, some days the bug.
=== MultiMail/Linux v0.52
--- SBBSecho 3.14-Win32
* Origin: Diamond Mine Online BBS - bbs.dmine.net:24 (1:275/89)

Hello, August!

Saturday January 22 2022 19:52, you wrote to me:

Thanks for the heads-up on that one. It's only for the 64bit
on Windows, but it might be a good replacement on one of my /64
systems just the same.

I am pretty sure that it has 32bit version: https://github.com/yt-dlp/yt-dlp/releases/tag/2022.01.21
yt-dlp_x86.exe

For me it works much better and faster than youtube-dl (YMMV).

Best regards,
dp.
--- GoldED+/W64-MSVC 1.1.5-b20180707
* Origin: No rest for the wicked (2:5001/100.1)

On 2022 Jan 23 10:52:00, you wrote to Rob Swindell:

BTW, I can confirm, youtube-dl is very slow (e.g. 52.56KiB/s) these
days. But I think it's been that way for a while now, at least for
me.

Same here. But only for YouTube. Other sites work much faster. So I think YouTube is throttling.

one way to find out would be to take a look at the sources and see what user agent is being used... then change it and see what happens... it may be that the tool is identifying itself and a more generic browser UA could be used...

[edit]

i just found the --dump-user-agent command line option... i don't see anything that appears to allow one to specify a different UA...

$ /usr/local/bin/youtube-dl --dump-user-agent
Mozilla/5.0 (Windows NT 10.0; Win64; x64) AppleWebKit/537.36 (KHTML, like Gecko) Chrome/73.0.3683.50 Safari/537.36

of course, YT might also be analyzing how the downloads are being done and throttling based on certain flow patterns they are seeing...

but then i look at the following and wonder...

$ /usr/local/bin/yt-dlp --dump-user-agent
Mozilla/5.0 (Windows NT 10.0; Win64; x64) AppleWebKit/537.36 (KHTML, like Gecko) Chrome/91.0.4472.164 Safari/537.36

the only difference i see is the Chrome version... hummm :thinking:

)\/(ark

"The soul of a small kitten in the body of a mighty dragon. Look on my majesty, ye mighty, and despair! Or bring me catnip. Your choice. Oooh, a shiny thing!"
... We're talking about sex, right? - Simpson, Homer
---
* Origin: (1:3634/12.73)

Hello Dmitry Protasoff!

** On Sunday 23.01.22 - 20:39, Dmitry Protasoff wrote to August Abolins:

I am pretty sure that it has 32bit version: https://github.com/yt-dlp/yt-dlp/releases/tag/2022.01.21
yt-dlp_x86.exe

I did not pay attention to that one further down the list of
releases. Thx.

For me it works much better and faster than youtube-dl (YMMV).

Looking forward to trying it.
--
../|ug
--- OpenXP 5.0.51
* Origin: (2:221/1.58)

Hello Ron Lauzon!

** On Sunday 23.01.22 - 10:52, Ron Lauzon wrote to Rob Swindell:

BTW, I can confirm, youtube-dl is very slow (e.g.
52.56KiB/s) these days. But I think it's been that way
for a while now, at least for me.

Same here. But only for YouTube. Other sites work much
faster. So I think YouTube is throttling.

youtube-dl seemed to keep up with the barriers it was facing on
YT with reasonable updates every now and then. Too bad, it
stopped development.
--
../|ug
--- OpenXP 5.0.51
* Origin: (2:221/1.58)

August Abolins wrote to Ron Lauzon <=-

youtube-dl seemed to keep up with the barriers it was facing on
YT with reasonable updates every now and then. Too bad, it
stopped development.

I just did a check (youtube-dl -U) and I'm up to date with a version date or 2021.12.17.

That doesn't seem to me like they stopped development.

I do recall that they went through a hosting problem some time ago so that you needed to reinstall youtube-dl because doing a 'youtube-dl -U' with the old version went to the old server, which wasn't there anymore.


... It is always darkest just before you turn on the lights.
=== MultiMail/Linux v0.52
--- SBBSecho 3.14-Win32
* Origin: Diamond Mine Online BBS - bbs.dmine.net:24 (1:275/89)

Hello Ron Lauzon!

** On Tuesday 25.01.22 - 08:19, Ron Lauzon wrote to August Abolins:

I just did a check (youtube-dl -U) and I'm up to date with a version date or 2021.12.17.

That doesn't seem to me like they stopped development.

That's pretty good then. My -U was always failing. The last
version that I have is 2021.06.06

I do recall that they went through a hosting problem some time ago so
that you needed to reinstall youtube-dl because doing a 'youtube-dl -U' with the old version went to the old server, which wasn't there anymore.

I will dl from the site and run that one.

--
../|ug

--- OpenXP 5.0.51
* Origin: (2:221/1.58)

Hello, August!
Saturday January 22 2022 19:52, you wrote to me:

Thanks for the heads-up on that one. It's only for the 64bit
on Windows, but it might be a good replacement on one of my /64
systems just the same.

I am pretty sure that it has 32bit version: https://github.com/yt-dlp/yt-dlp/releases/tag/2022.01.21
yt-dlp_x86.exe
For me it works much better and faster than youtube-dl (YMMV).
Best regards,
dp.

THIS one operates in full speed. THX!

youtube-dl -f 18 https://youtu.be/vIeFt88Hm8s

[youtube] vIeFt88Hm8s: Downloading webpage [download] Destination: Joe Rogan Experience #1208 - Jordan Peterson-vIeFt88Hm8s.mp4
[download] 100% of 457.40MiB in 02:44:07
^^^^^^^

yt-dlp -f 18 https://youtu.be/vIeFt88Hm8s

[youtube] vIeFt88Hm8s: Downloading webpage [youtube] vIeFt88Hm8s: Downloading android player API JSON [youtube] vIeFt88Hm8s: Downloading player 495d0f2b [info] vIeFt88Hm8s: Downloading 1 format(s): 18 [download] Destination: Joe Rogan Experience #1208 - Jordan Peterson [vIeFt88Hm8s].mp4
[download] 4.7% of 457.40MiB at 610.51KiB/s ETA 12:11
^^^^^^ ^^^^^^^^^


--- BBBS/Li6 v4.10 Toy-5
* Origin: The Rusty MailBox - Penticton, BC Canada (1:153/757)

Hello Dmitry Protasoff!

** On Sunday 23.01.22 - 20:39, Dmitry Protasoff wrote to August Abolins:

I am pretty sure that it has 32bit version: https://github.com/yt-dlp/yt-dlp/releases/tag/2022.01.21
yt-dlp_x86.exe

For me it works much better and faster than youtube-dl (YMMV).

Confirmed. yt-dlp is full-speed even on YT.

But the yt-dlp_x86.exe version does not run on my XP/32. :(

--
../|ug
--- OpenXP 5.0.51
* Origin: (2:221/1.58)