I wonder what killed shop class? Focusing on ranking / test scores?
I was thinking about how lucky I was -- without realizing it at the time of course -- to go to a public school that offered so many classes that weren't focused on academics.
We had worthwhile home-ec (where you actually learned by doing for cooking, food safety, balancing a budget, cleaning)... all manner of shop classes -- I took auto, metal and wood shop classes -- we had typing and programming classes too, and teachers who'd stay after school for hours encouraging and helping you.
This was in the mid-1990s and it's still wild to me to think that they let 16 years old's drive their 20 year old 4500lb domestic beasts into a repair bay, put them up on a 2-post lift, and do actual work in a semi-supervised environment (I think we had a 10 kids and 1 instructor, there were two
In high school I spent hours after school working in the Mac lab which was filled with Centris 610's -- we were learning on Think Pascal and would travel around to different HS programming competitions (most of the time it was a team of 4 selected and we'd pile into the teacher's LeSabre on a weekend and he'd drive us an hour to a nearby college hosting the event).
Dux wrote to All <=-
I wonder what killed shop class? Focusing on ranking / test scores? Bubble-wrapping kids' school lives? Sucking the joy/benefits out of transitioning from trades to education leaving the schools filled with only career educators who went from college to teaching without gaining any real world experience?
I wonder what killed shop class?
Some of what was said earlier is true. I graduated high school back in '81. We had building construction, Ag shop, regular shop, drafting, beauty, and computer class. Also home ec and automotive. We had to program in Pascal and type them on a punched card and run it though a reader.
I taught in small East Texas schools in the late 90's early 2000's and you still had ag shop, home ec, automotive and computer class. They all were watered down from what we did in the 80's. Computer class was mostly excel and word.
I was a history, econ and gov't teacher and in my econ class, I had a guy from a car dealership and a realtor come in and spoke to the seniors
about buying a car and a house. We also did a checkbook exercise to learn how to open an account and keep up with finances. This was nnot in the TEKS at the time. I don't know it is now. I haven't been in a classroom in 15 or
Dux wrote to All <=-
We had worthwhile home-ec (where you actually learned by doing for cooking, food safety, balancing a budget, cleaning)... all manner of
shop classes -- I took auto, metal and wood shop classes -- we had
typing and programming classes too, and teachers who'd stay after
school for hours encouraging and helping you.
I look at what the same school system offers now and it's pretty depressing -- the town has stayed socio-economically similar, but the classes now are focused almost entirely on academic work, geared toward testing, and they don't have a single shop class left other than a solitary robotics offering.
I wonder what killed shop class? Focusing on ranking / test scores? Bubble-wrapping kids' school lives? Sucking the joy/benefits out of transitioning from trades to education leaving the schools filled with only career educators who went from college to teaching without gaining any real world experience?
I saw a discussion over on the Unix board where folks were mentioning their first experiences with computers at school, and access to some
other classes like typing.
didn't do much. in middle school we had home ec and shop class. in home ec we just cooked a few things. We had sewing as well. I can not remember how to thread a sewing machine. We didn't learn how to balance a budget or anything.
we had computer courses in iigs. nothing serious and no programming.
we just typed up assignments.
I wonder what killed shop class? Focusing on ranking / test scores?
I wonder what killed shop class?
I always assumed it was insurance issues...
I was thinking about how lucky I was -- without realizing it at the time of course -- to go to a public school that offered so many classes that weren't focused on academics.
We had worthwhile home-ec (where you actually learned by doing for cooking, food safety, balancing a budget, cleaning)... all manner of shop classes -- I took auto, metal and wood shop classes -- we had typing and programming classes too, and teachers who'd stay after school for hours encouraging and helping you.
In high school I spent hours after school working in the Mac lab which was filled with Centris 610's -- we were learning on Think Pascal and would travel around to different HS programming competitions (most of the time it was a team of 4 selected and we'd pile into the teacher's LeSabre on a weekend and he'd drive us an hour to a nearby college hosting the event). We'd also have what seemed like epic Bolo matches with a dozen or so people playing.
I wonder what killed shop class? Focusing on ranking / test scores?
In my school district, we had all Apple II hardwares. I believe in much later years they had some Macintosh boxes and then the PCs came in high
Dunno about that. Maybe.
People in high-school age all want to be bloggers and youtubers and they all take academic paths if given the option. You never see any youngster hoping to be an electrician anymore, so my hypothesis is there is not much interest in workshop-style work.
--
The 'PC is too hard' thing reminds me, my parents sent me a nerd-camp at
a local college when I was in elementary school and middle school -- the modeled it after college, you'd sign up for classes and move through the day between them...
We'd sit air conditioned labs working on IBM 5150's to create programs in Du> GW-BASIC, at the end of each session we'd print out our program and a Du> sample run on 11x17 green bar tractor paper to bring home, and save it to Du> a 5.25" floppy we were assigned, at the end of each summer we'd bring the Du> floppy home
Arelor wrote to Dux <=-
My high-school had tons of well equiped workshops, but that is because
the center was designed to be a trade training center and academic
plans were an afterthought. They had engine labs and electronics labs
and whatever have you because back in the day they trained
professionals to fix engines and radios.
The advantage is if you were taking academic studies instead of
learning a trade you would still get access to the labs from time to
time. Designing a PCB on a piece of paper is nice, building it in a lab
is golden. Watching the bully asshole get splashed with boric acid
because he didn't follow safety instructions is priceless.
--
gopher://gopher.richardfalken.com/1/richardfalken
---
Synchronet Palantir BBS * palantirbbs.ddns.net * Pensacola, FL
Arelor wrote to Bf2k+ <=-
People in high-school age all want to be bloggers and youtubers and
they all take academic paths if given the option. You never see any youngster hoping to be an electrician anymore, so my hypothesis is
there is not much interest in workshop-style work.
Retro Guy wrote to Dux <=-
We had a photography club (a science teacher, about 5 kids and a
darkroom) and it was great. Learned how to develop film, etc. I
finished high school in 1982, so not much for computers for me.
paulie420 wrote to Dux <=-
LOL - That sounds like something I'd of loved... while I had access to
a 5150, and then jumped into clones at my own house, I missed the programming bit until a lot later. Started w/ games, moved over to PD BBSing - then pirate BBSing, hacking, other activities and THEN programming by necessity. :P
My high-school had tons of well equiped workshops, but that is because the center was designed to be a trade training center and academic
plans were an afterthought. They had engine labs and electronics labs and whatever have you because back in the day they trained
professionals to fix engines and radios.
Around here in California, that seems to have moved to the junior
college level. There are JCs that are intended as a place for people to
get their lower-division classes done in a cheaper, easier to enter
environment, with some assurances that classes will transfer 1:1 into
the university of California system.
People in high-school age all want to be bloggers and youtubers and
they all take academic paths if given the option. You never see any youngster hoping to be an electrician anymore, so my hypothesis is
there is not much interest in workshop-style work.
True, but back in the 1980s when I went to school, cars were simple.
Carbs, points, distributors, voltage regulators. No computers. You could
buy a bitchin' 1970s Camaro and spend your free time with it on the
lift, doing all sorts of work you couldn't do in your driveway - and
with access to a killer set of tools.
I'll admit we were all nerds, but if they could manage to get 20 4th graders to boot PCs, open GW-BASIC, and build simple programs it couldn't have been /that/ bad...
True, but back in the 1980s when I went to school, cars were simple. Carbs, points, distributors, voltage regulators. No computers. You could buy a bitchin' 1970s Camaro and spend your free time with it on the lift, doing all sorts of work you couldn't do in your driveway - and with access to a killer set of tools.
In Kentucky, that would be the community colleges, although there are high schools that also still offer college credits for some things.
True, but back in the 1980s when I went to school, cars were simple. Carbs,
points, distributors, voltage regulators. No computers. You could buy a
bitchin' 1970s Camaro and spend your free time with it on the lift, doing
all sorts of work you couldn't do in your driveway - and with access to a
killer set of tools.
For many years I had a 1980 Chevrolet Monte Carlo that was first purchased i California. I hate to tell you this, but cars sold in California back then did indeed have computers in them in order to regulate the "California emmissions" systems they had to be equiped with in order to be sold there.
I agree.. I got experience using my dad's computers when I was growing up, and he gave me my own (hand-me-down) PC when I was 12, just after 6th grade.
Re: Re: Old School
By: Dumas Walker to POINDEXTER FORTRAN
on Mon Jan 06 2025 09:01 am
In Kentucky, that would be the community colleges, although there are high schools that also still offer college credits for some things.
My kids are clamoring for AP classes because they're more "fun" than the basic classes - what they don't know yet is that senior year AP classes can be used for college credit, which makes scheduling the first year of college much easier.
Digital Man wrote to poindexter FORTRAN <=-
I thought I'd let you know: your message came through here with
embedded ANSI escape sequences (the Re/By/On header info up there),
which defeats the word/line wrap in Synchronet (we don't try to wrap ANSI-encoded messages).
Normally, DOVE-Net messages are exchanged between Synchronet systems
using Ctrl-A codes (instead of ANSI) whenever possible. Can you double-check your settings in SCFG->Networks->QWK->Hubs->VERT against
the instructions here: https://wiki.synchro.net/howto:dove-net
asicIn Kentucky, that would be the community colleges, although there are high schools that also still offer college credits for some things.
My kids are clamoring for AP classes because they're more "fun" than the
classes - what they don't know yet is that senior year AP classes can be used for college credit, which makes scheduling the first year of college much easier.
That's odd, the hub was set to "expand", I've set it to "leave in". I haven't touched this in some time.
Is there a preferred per-area setting? I have "export ASCII only" set to "no" in the area configuration.
In Kentucky, that would be the community colleges, although there are high schools that also still offer college credits for some things.
I hate to tell you this, but cars sold in California back
then did indeed have computers in them in order to regulate the "California emmissions" systems they had to be equiped with in order to be sold there.
You wanted to learn welding basics, metal working, household electrical work, etc, there were 2-3 month long classes that would meet 1-2x week at night and you'd pay a couple of hundred bucks, maybe a bit more.
Those don't seem to exist around here anymore -- and haven't for a long time because I can remember seeing them when I was kid at 10-15 in the "community education" fliers we'd get, but by the time I was 25-30 those were gone. The best you could get was to sign up for a certificate series which was often several thousand dollars or more.
...and about a mile of vaccuum hoses too.olenoids
I have a late 70s domestic car I keep around, it's not as bad as the 80s versions but still has plenty of emissions/mileage stuff. Once they got into air/smog pumps it really started to go wild under the hood. In some ways a modern vehicle is actually simplier because computers and electronic
aren't as complex as the vaccuum controlled systems.
it was a hose problem (from experience) but I was not able to find which hose was causing it. It was one that was semi-hidden under and behind some things over the back of the engine.
There were the "usual suspect" hoses, but that one was a new one. ;)
Dux wrote to Dumas Walker <=-
Those don't seem to exist around here anymore -- and haven't for a long time because I can remember seeing them when I was kid at 10-15 in the "community education" fliers we'd get
Dux wrote to Dumas Walker <=-
some ways a modern vehicle is actually simplier because computers and electronic solenoids aren't as complex as the vaccuum controlled
systems.
One of my favorite cars are early '80s Mercedes W123s - the midsized diesel sedans and wagons. Apparently a ton of functions on the car are powered by vacuum systems - power door locks, the transmission system, the brake booster... Debugging the system is a nightmare, but I suppose you could just use the mantra "follow the suck".
https://youtu.be/lTSWdHY9Ny4?si=PfY28S2GfsaoclNy
Not sure it is the whole reason, but part of the reason could be
that unions don't want any additional competition from shade tree
welders or electrical handymen, i.e. people who might do these
things on the side without proper certification or appreticeship but
also without paying union dues.
Oh, that reminded me of the Learning Annex. Don't know if they were
around everywhere, but in the San Francisco bay area their booklets
were *everywhere*. Classes seemed a mixture of entrepreneurial, new-age
and single-mingly classes that seemed designed to facilitate hookups.
How to pole dance? How to shoot your own adult video? Kabbalah dating?
FYI, and maybe this will help some people's possible handed down opinions (or just lack of first hand experience) in the future. As a union ironworker, my union dues are $42 a month. When your pay and benefits are almost 2x better than any non-union job, the dues (that I don't even write a check out for, or pay manually) goes almost unnoticed. In 18 years in the trade, I've never heard a single person complain about dues.
On the other hand, we pay like $13+ an HOUR for our health and welfare.
Many
people complain about that, but not dues.
Put it this way, a journeyman ironworker is billed out at like ~$75/hr
(base
rate) plus whatever the employer adds a percentage to it for some kind of profit, I imagine. Off the top of that, comes dues, health insurance,
I wonder what killed shop class? Focusing on ranking / test scores? Bubble-wrapping kids' school lives? Sucking the
joy/benefits out of transitioning from trades to education leaving the schools filled with only career educators who went
from college to teaching without gaining any real world experience?
Re: Old School
By: Dux to All on Thu Jan 02 2025 11:42 pm
I always assumed it was insurance issues...
---
Synchronet TIRED of waiting 2 hours for a taco? GO TO
TACOPRONTO.bbs.io
1983 here, my senior year was the first time I programmed on a
computer. We had a lab with several Commodore CBM machines and wrote a
ton of BASIC.
I wish we had a photo club, I would have loved to get into photography
early. It wasn't until later, when I'd been into photography for
several years that I took my first darkroom class. By that time it was
interesting learning physical techniques for things we take for granted
in digital photography.
--- MultiMail/Win v0.52
Synchronet .: realitycheckbbs.org :: scientia potentia est :.
union ironworker, my union dues are $42 a month. When your pay and
benefits are almost 2x better than any non-union job, the dues (that I don't even write a check out for, or pay manually) goes almost
well i've been a bit of a job jumper after leaving my job of 17
years. I've worked at places that had unions that were total
dogshit. The benefits were not on par with non union companies and
the progression and pay was poor. Your experience in you union is
not the norm in today's age. Especially in wisconsin where you
don't even have to be in a union in a 'union shop'
There's a lot of unions that just side with the company and don't do
anyting for their workers.
Sadly, things are not like they used to be.
Not going to go into too many details here, but I have personally
seen wages and benefits go DOWN after union's came in. Most
recently last year, people went from $24 an hour to $19.60 an hour
and benefits while on par with what the company had offered were
twice as expensive as here in Canada a union is a FOR PROFIT
business.
The last union I was forced into back in the 90's, I went from $9.50
an hour to $6.85 an hour. Plus I had to pay union dues of $22 every
2 weeks.
Those were some $$$$$$ union dues when you make $6.85 an hour. That
company went out of business 6 months after the union came in, they
didn't have any employees left.
I'm not anti-union, but I don't believe they should be a for profit
business.
There's a lot of unions that just side with the company and don't do anyting for their workers.
Sadly, things are not like they used to be.
I believe it, however, there's a huge difference between factory/shop
unions
(which can even include sitting on an assembly line packaging cheese, ffs) and construction trade unions.
Either way, this was brought up because of dues and the negativity behind them. Were any dues you ever paid ever a burden on you in your line of work? Because in any construction trade, they are basically unnoticeable.
Compare it to a financial advisor taking a small percentage from your
funds,
for taking care of your money for you. Nobody complains about that. :)
I believe it, however, there's a huge difference between factory/shop unions (which can even include sitting on an assembly line packaging cheese, ffs) and
construction trade unions.
Either way, this was brought up because of dues and the negativity behind them
Actually, I made the initial comment because someone brought up
learning to do what could be considered "trade work" at adult/
continuing education classes.
It was not really meant as an anti-union swipe, but I do suspect
that those types of classes are frowned on by unions (and
professional groups and government agencies) because someone can
learn to do work without (1) being properly licensed and
apprenticed, and (2) paying licensing fees or dues.
I think that is pretty much SOP so I didn't see it as a swipe.
I had never heard of that union before I worked there, so the
opinion I formed of that particular union is not good.
Neither of them were the UAW, BTW. ;)
My point being that some of them are good for their members, and
some really are not.
I didn't either, to be honest. I just know "dues" are one of the major arguing points of anti-union people, and wanted to make it clear that dues are a very small drop in the bucket.
I had never heard of that union before I worked there, so the
I think that is pretty much SOP so I didn't see it as a swipe.
I didn't either, to be honest. I just know "dues" are one of the major arguing
points of anti-union people, and wanted to make it clear that dues are a very small drop in the bucket.
I had never heard of that union before I worked there, so the
opinion I formed of that particular union is not good.
Neither of them were the UAW, BTW. ;)
Maybe not, but the UAW did have a major part in starting the negativity toward
unions. And what happened because of it has probably directly reflected many other shop unions, to this day.
My point being that some of them are good for their members, and
some really are not.
Agreed there. And the ones that are not may be better off not being a union, since that is the driving force behind them (looking out for their workers, etc).
For instance, teamsters is going after amazon and trying to blur the line between dsps and the actual company. That's big money if they get amazon. Strange thing is, they aren't going after fedex ground and express because those are all contractors ran by hundreds of companys as well.
For instance, teamsters is going after amazon and trying to blur the line between dsps and the actual company. That's big money if they get amazon. Strange thing is, they aren't going after fedex ground and express because those are all contractors ran by hundreds of companys as well.
That is a good example. If the workers want the union, that is one
thing,
but when unions go after other sources of members, that is somewhat of an illustration of what I was talking about. They want those people paying dues.
Teamsters do this fake amazon strike that never happened. they pay their people to stand outside an amazon, they take photos and vids with signs and they go home.
Teamsters do this fake amazon strike that never happened. they pay their people to stand outside an amazon, they take photos and vids with signs and they go home.
That would explain why I kept seeing things about the Amazon strike in the news and yet did not stop seeing the delivery people out everywhere.
Sysop: | deepend |
---|---|
Location: | Calgary, Alberta |
Users: | 257 |
Nodes: | 10 (0 / 10) |
Uptime: | 60:00:34 |
Calls: | 1,792 |
Files: | 4,168 |
D/L today: |
6 files (1,004K bytes) |
Messages: | 395,167 |